If you’ve ever had a week where your home coffee is great on Monday and a bit weird by Thursday, you’re not alone. Most of the time it’s not your machine “playing up”. It’s freshness, dose drift, grind drift, or all three.
A coffee subscription sounds like a convenience play, and sure, it helps. But the real upside is consistency. When your beans arrive on a rhythm, you can build a brew rhythm to match. That’s where home coffee starts to feel easy.
In this post I’ll walk you through how we think about a Brew Better subscription at Grace & Taylor, how to choose one without overthinking it, and how to get better results from each delivery with a few simple, repeatable brew habits. We’ll keep it practical, with real numbers.
(And yes, we drink our own coffee. If we didn’t, Keith would yell at me. Politely.)
What a coffee subscription actually changes
Most people chase “better coffee” by changing gear. Grinder, machine, fancy dripper, new gadgets that need their own shelf.
A subscription flips that. It improves the one part that affects every brew method, the ingredient.
Here’s what changes when you get coffee delivered regularly:
-
You shorten the stale window. You drink more of the bag in its best phase, not the tail end where everything tastes flatter.
-
You reduce random buying. Fewer emergency supermarket runs, fewer “this will do” beans.
-
You can dial in properly. Repetition is how you learn. One coffee, a handful of adjustments, then you lock it in and enjoy it.
-
Reduce your spend. All our subscription products offer a saving off the regular price. Meaning not only do you get great coffee, you get to save, with less frequent checkouts and stress over when your next order will arrive.
That’s the real value. Freshly roasted coffee on a schedule, and enough consistency to actually get good at brewing it.
Freshness is not a vibe, it’s chemistry
Roasted coffee holds a lot of carbon dioxide. It slowly releases over time (degassing). That matters because gas affects flow, extraction, and flavour. If you brew too soon, espresso in particular can behave like it has somewhere else to be.
On the other end, coffee that’s been sitting around oxidises. It loses aromatics, tastes dull, and the finish gets papery. You can grind finer to force more extraction, but you’re mostly extracting more sadness.
A good routine is simple:
-
For espresso: Brew from 7 days after roast (can be flexible, but this is a good starting point), then expect the grind to move slightly over the next week or two.
-
For filter: you can start sooner, and the flavour window tends to feel wider.
This is one reason a coffee subscription works so well. You don’t need to be perfect, you just need a repeatable rhythm.
How to choose a coffee subscription without overthinking it
There are lots of formats out there, but your decision comes down to three things:
1) Brew method
Pick a subscription that matches your daily setup.
-
If you mostly drink milk coffees, choose a reliable espresso blend.
-
If you drink black coffee, or love lighter cups, choose filter coffee beans or a rotating single origin subscription..
2) How much coffee you actually drink
This sounds obvious, but it’s where most subscriptions go wrong. People order like they’re running a café, then wonder why the bag lasts forever.
A rough guide for home use:
-
One double espresso a day is about 18 to 20 g of coffee.
-
A single filter brew might be 15 g.
Do the maths with your household routine, then choose a delivery cycle that keeps you moving through the bag while it still tastes alive.
3) Do you want “set and forget”, or variety
Both are valid.
-
Set and forget: you learn one coffee, get very consistent, and your mornings run smoothly.
-
Variety: you keep it interesting, but you accept you’ll do more dial-in work.
Neither is more “specialty” than the other. The best coffee subscription is the one you’ll actually stick with.
The dial-in basics that make a subscription worth it
Once your first order arrives and you’re on a delivery rhythm. The goal is to make small changes, on purpose, instead of random tweaks.
At Grace & Taylor we keep the language simple: extraction is how much you dissolve from the coffee, strength is how concentrated the brew is. They’re not the same thing, and confusing them is how people end up pulling very short, very intense shots that taste sharp and incomplete.
A simple pattern holds up across methods:
-
If it tastes sour, sharp, or salty, push extraction up.
-
If it tastes bitter, hollow, or aggressively drying, fix any unevenness, then if necessary, pull extraction back
Below are practical starting points you can use with each delivery.
Espresso: a simple, repeatable starting recipe
Here’s our favourite home baseline. It’s not magic, it’s just stable:
-
Dose: 20 g
-
Yield (the weight of espresso): 40 g (a 1:2 ratio)
-
Time: 25 to 35 seconds from pump start
We use 20 g as a default because it keeps the maths simple and repeatable.
Step 1: Set your dose and yield
Lock those two in first.
If you’re using a smaller basket, you might need to drop dose a bit. If you do, keep the ratio logic the same.
Step 2: Adjust grind to hit the yield in a sensible time
-
If you hit 40 g in 18 seconds, grind finer.
-
If you hit 40 g in 45 seconds and it looks choked, grind coarser.
Then taste.
Step 3: If flavour is still off, adjust ratio before you chase time
Time is mostly a result of grind, dose, puck prep, and the ratio you chose. Don’t worship it. If a shot tastes great at 19 seconds, congratulations, you’ve got a tasty coffee.
If the shot tastes sharp and underdone, keep the dose the same and increase yield, for example 20 g in, 45 g out. That often fixes the “too short, too strong” trap without resorting to bigger doses.
Filter: one recipe that works for most coffees
If you brew V60 or similar pour over, start here:
-
Coffee: 15 g
-
Water: 250 g (about 1:16.5)
-
Water temp: 93 to 100 °C
-
Total time: 2:45 to 3:30
The basics matter more than fancy pours:
-
Rinse the paper.
-
Bloom with about 30 g water for 30 to 45 seconds.
-
Pour in a few steady pulses, keep the bed wet, don’t blast the sides.
If it tastes sour and thin, grind finer. If it tastes dry and woody, grind coarser and ease off agitation.
The one habit that makes home coffee better fast
Write down three numbers for each coffee:
-
Dose
-
Yield (or total brew water)
-
Grind setting
That’s it.
Storage: how to keep your subscription coffee tasting good
Storing coffee well is mostly about avoiding oxygen, heat, light, and moisture.
A practical home setup:
-
Keep the bag sealed between uses, or use an airtight container.
-
Store it in a cool cupboard, not next to the oven.
-
Don’t put it in the fridge. The moisture and odours are not your friend.
If you buy larger bags, portioning can help. Split into smaller airtight containers so you only expose a week’s worth at a time.
This is another quiet benefit of buying coffee beans online that are delivered regularly. You can order closer to what you use, rather than buying big “just in case” bags that hang around.
“But I want it to taste the same every time”
Totally fair. That’s most of us on weekdays.
If you want consistency, pick a blend you love and stick with it. You’ll still tweak grind as the coffee ages, but your dial-in moves will be small and predictable.
If you want variety, choose a rotating subscription and expect a short dial-in period each time. That’s not a failure, it’s the cost of changing the variables.
Either way, the same rule holds: get the coffee fresh, then make small adjustments with intent.
The ethics bit, quietly, because it matters
We buy higher quality green coffees through importers we trust. That access to better lots is part of why the coffee tastes sweeter and more complete when you extract it well. We share origin context where it’s useful, but we don’t overshare details that should stay private.
If you’re choosing between subscriptions, it’s worth looking for that calm, factual approach. Good coffee and respectful sourcing usually look like boring consistency, not big claims.
A quick checklist before you start
When your next coffee delivery lands, do this:
-
Brew it the same way you brewed the last bag, as a starting point.
-
If it’s sharp or sour, push extraction up (usually grind finer, or a slightly higher ratio).
-
If it’s bitter and drying, pull extraction back (usually grind coarser), and double-check puck prep or agitation.
-
Write down dose, yield, grind.
-
Enjoy the fact you’re not buying random beans at 9 pm.
That’s it. No heroics.
Choosing your lane: decaf, single origin, curated, espresso blends
Not all coffee subscriptions are built for the same job. Here’s how to pick the right style, based on how you actually drink coffee at home.
Espresso blends
If you want reliability, start here. Espresso blends are built to be consistent across weeks, sit up in milk, and stay forgiving when your grind drifts a touch. Expect steady sweetness, balanced acidity, and a finish that does not get weird the moment your shot runs two seconds fast.
Single origin coffees
Single origin is where you taste the specific character of a place and process. These coffees can be brighter, more aromatic, and a bit more sensitive to recipe changes. Great if you drink black coffee, or you enjoy dialing in. If you make milk coffees, single origin can still work, but you may want a slightly higher ratio on espresso to keep it sweet and complete. Feel free to reach out to us to find out which single origins we recommend for milk coffees.
Decaf
Decaf should still taste like coffee, not a compromise. The main trick is treating it like its own coffee, not “espresso, but weaker”. Decaf often likes a slightly finer grind and careful puck prep to keep flow even. If you drink coffee later in the day, or you want a calm option that still holds up as espresso or filter, decaf in a subscription keeps it fresh and genuinely enjoyable.
Curated
A curated subscription is for people who want variety without doing the homework. We rotate coffees based on what is tasting best on the cupping table and what’s behaving well on brew. The trade-off is you will do a small dial-in each new bag. The upside is you get range, and you build brewing skills fast because you learn how different coffees respond to the same recipe.
Brewing methods: match the coffee to how you brew
If you are choosing a coffee subscription, it helps to pick coffees that suit your daily brewer. Each method rewards a slightly different roast style, grind range, and recipe.
AeroPress
AeroPress is the most forgiving way to make a strong, clean cup fast. It works well with both espresso blends and single origin coffees. Start with 15 g coffee to 250 g water, 92 to 96 °C, steep 2:00, then press slowly for 20 to 30 seconds. If it tastes sharp, grind a touch finer or extend steep time. If it tastes heavy and drying, grind coarser and shorten the steep.
Espresso
Espresso is the most sensitive to small changes, but it gives the most repeatable routine once dialled in. Espresso blends are the easiest place to start, especially if you drink milk coffee. Use a stable baseline like 1:2 ratio (for example 20 g in, 40 g out), then adjust grind to control flow and adjust ratio to control flavour balance. If it tastes sour or salty, push extraction up (often a finer grind or slightly higher yield). If it tastes bitter and drying, pull extraction back (often a coarser grind).
Moka pot (stovetop espresso maker)
Moka pot sits between espresso and filter. It likes coffees that are sweet and structured, so espresso blends are a strong fit, and some single origins can be excellent if they are not too delicate. Use hot water in the base, fill the basket level (do not tamp), and brew on medium heat. Aim for a steady, quiet flow rather than spluttering. If it tastes harsh, grind coarser and reduce heat. If it tastes thin, grind slightly finer.
Plunger (French press)
Plunger is simple and reliable, with a heavier body and more texture. It suits espresso blends and rounder single origins. Start with 60 g per litre (so 15 g to 250 g water), 94 to 98 °C, steep 4:00, then plunge gently. If it tastes muddy or bitter, grind coarser and pour more gently. If it tastes weak, increase the dose slightly before you chase a finer grind.
V60 pour over
V60 highlights clarity and aroma. It is a great match for single origin coffees and lighter profiles. Start at 15 g coffee to 250 g water, 93 to 100 °C, total time 2:45 to 3:30. Rinse the paper, bloom for 30 to 45 seconds, then pour in steady pulses. If it tastes sour and thin, grind finer. If it tastes astringent and drying, grind coarser and reduce agitation.
Stovetop
If by “stovetop” you mean something other than a moka pot, the same rules still apply: control heat, avoid violent boiling, and aim for a smooth flow. Stovetop brewing rewards coffees with sweetness and structure, and it punishes over extraction quickly. Keep the heat moderate, and adjust the grind to manage harshness before you change the coffee.
If you want one simple rule for all of these: lock in a repeatable recipe first, then change one thing at a time. That is how a subscription stops being “beans on a schedule” and becomes a reliable brew routine.
Final thought: specialty coffee subscriptions are a brewing tool
A Brew Better subscription from Grace & Taylor is not just a delivery service. It’s a way to make your inputs predictable, so you can make your brewing predictable.
If you want to get better at coffee at home, consistency beats intensity. Fresh coffee, a stable recipe, and tiny adjustments done on purpose.
And if you’re already a subscriber with us, thanks. You’re basically helping us keep the roaster warm and the spreadsheet honest.
